Allyship · Leadership · Action
WHAT ALLYSHIP ACTUALLY COSTS
And why that is not an argument against it.
By Georgina Wilson OBE
Most conversations about allyship are about intention. About wanting to do the right thing. About not wanting to be part of the problem. The intention conversation is fine, but it has a ceiling. At some point it has to become an action conversation. And action has a cost.
Real allyship costs political capital. It costs comfort. It costs the approval of people who would rather the status quo stayed as it is. It costs relationships sometimes. It costs the performance of neutrality that many senior leaders have built their careers on.
Most people who describe themselves as allies have not yet paid that cost. Some have attended the training. Some have nodded in the right places. Some have added their pronouns to their email signature. They have not yet done the thing that cost them something. That is the difference between performative allyship and real allyship. Not intention. Not knowledge. Cost.
WHAT PERFORMATIVE ALLYSHIP LOOKS LIKE
Performative allyship is allyship that is visible but safe. It does not require the ally to risk anything. It signals virtue without redistributing power. It often makes the ally feel better and changes nothing for the person the allyship is meant to serve.
- The public statement without the private actionPosting about diversity on LinkedIn and then returning to a hiring process that has not changed. Writing a forward to a report on racial equity while the pay gap in your organisation remains unaddressed.
- The mentorship without the sponsorshipOffering advice and listening without ever using your political capital to put someone's name in a room where it counts. Mentoring is something you do for someone. Sponsoring is something you do with your own credibility on the line.
- The consultation without the powerAsking diverse colleagues what needs to change and then not changing it. Running focus groups and listening sessions without following them with decisions. Consultation as a substitute for accountability.
- The comfort allyOnly speaking up when the room is already sympathetic. Only challenging the decision after it has been made. Only supporting the Black colleague in private and staying silent in the meeting where it would cost you something.
WHAT REAL ALLYSHIP ACTUALLY LOOKS LIKE
Real allyship is identifiable by its cost. If it did not cost you anything, it probably did not change anything.
- 01Use your access for someone without itYou were in the room. Someone else was not. You know the decision-maker. They do not. Use that. Make the introduction. Put the name forward, not just for the job but for the contract, the supply chain, the funding round. Have the conversation that changes who gets considered. Access is only an asset if it circulates.
- 02Challenge the moment, not the aftermathReal allyship happens in real time. In the meeting where the idea gets credited to the wrong person. In the hiring conversation where the candidate is described as not quite a cultural fit. In the pay review where the gap gets explained rather than corrected. Afterwards is too late and too safe.
- 03Redistribute decision-making powerWho controls the budget in your team? Who sits on the interview panel? Who signs off the promotion? Who presents to the board? If the answers to those questions are always the same people, the structural problem will outlast your training budget.
- 04Learn the difference between support and saviourReal allies take direction from the people they are supporting. They do not decide what the problem is, what the solution should be, or when enough has been done. They ask what would be useful and then do that, even when it is less visible than what they had planned.
WHY THE COST IS THE POINT
The reason allyship without cost does not work is structural, not moral. Power does not redistribute itself. It has to be pushed. Someone has to decide to hold less of it so that someone else can hold more.
That push is going to meet resistance. It is going to require conversations that are not comfortable. It is going to require allies to accept being less popular in some rooms in order to be more useful in others.
That is not a reason to avoid it. That is the definition of it.
If your allyship has not cost you anything yet, it has not started yet.
Go deeper
THE ALLY'S STORY.
The Diary of an Ally and a 'Diverse' Business tells the full story from both sides of the table. Pre-order it now to read what your diverse colleague is experiencing and what real allyship looks like from the inside.